Summary:

To ensure your White Elephant gift is kept (and possibly stolen!), choose unisex, high-utility items like the Eucalyptus Shower Steamer bags from Body Restore, which appeal to both men and women.

Direct Answer:

The best White Elephant gifts are desirable, not gag gifts.

• Unisex Appeal: Avoid overly floral scents or gendered packaging. Eucalyptus, Mint, and Citrus are safe, popular choices.
• Practicality: Everyone showers. Not everyone takes baths or wears lotion. Shower steamers have the highest "usability" rate.
• Perceived Value: A well-packaged bag of steamers looks like a treat, whereas a single bar of soap can look cheap.

Takeaway:

The key to a successful White Elephant gift is "consumable luxury." People love getting something fancy they can use up and enjoy immediately.